- A Pittsburgh Penguins Blog © 2009
Thursday, November 06, 2008

The Case Against Trading Jordan Staal

It's one of the comments you'll most likely hear after a game: "The Penguins should trade Jordan Staal."  He's undoubtably the one Penguin with the most trade rumours swirling around him.  Looking at papers and blogs and message boards, it seems to be a pretty popular opinion - no one is showing any love for the boy from Thunder Bay.  People have wanted him off of this team since day one.  Jordan Staal was drafted in the 2006 NHL Entry Draft with the second overall pick and as soon as he was chosen people were already criticizing him.

And those critics seem to get louder with every game.  "They should have picked Toews," they say.  "Kessel would have been a better choice," say others.  There would be some, especially since he recently won NHL Rookie of the Month, who would rather have Derick Brassard in black and gold.  But they didn't get their wish.  Jordan Staal was a Pittsburgh Penguin.

But when Jordan took to the ice he started to shut some people up.  He was the youngest player to ever score two shorthanded goals in one game.  He was also the youngest to score on a penalty shot and the youngest to score a hat trick.  And he kept scoring.  He ended his rookie season with 29 goals, 42 points and seven shorthanded goals - a rookie record.  He was nominated for the
Calder trophy, but lost out to teammate Evgeni Malkin.  It seemed certain that Jordan would be a star.

And then he started to struggle.  Entering his second season he fell into what many would call a "sophmore slump."  His goal total dropped to 12 on the season  and he spent most of the year centering the team's third line.  And it hasn't gotten much better this year.  Going into tomorrow night's game against Edmonton Staal only has one goal and three assists.  And the goal was an
empty netter.  And so the calls for a trade have grown once again.  Even mainstream news outlets are discussing it now.  Dave Molinari at the Post-Gazette answered this same question just yesterday.

People want Staal gone.

And the case for trading him is convincing.  First of all, his production dropped drastically last year and, although it's early, he doesn't seem to be on track this year either.  Secondly, he's a center.  So is Sidney Crosby.  And Evgeni Malkin.  And, while we're at it, so is Max Talbot and Tyler Kennedy and Mike Zigomanis.  That's seven centers for four lines and that brings us to another point; Staal was moved to left wing alongside Evgeni Malkin and Petr Sykora this year and it didn't pay off.  He plays his best hockey at center and, on this team, that means you're on the third line at best (unless Therrien decides to put Crosby and Malkin together again.)

So we have a poorly producing center on a team filled with centers.  It seems like those who want him moved are right, doesn't it?

They're not.

They're not for one major reason.  Jordan Staal turned 20 less than two months ago.  Even if he was invited to a bachelor party in the US today, he will STILL be unable to drink
legally.  He's still the youngest regular player on this team. Is he Sidney Crosby or Evgeni Malkin?  No, and he probably never will be.  But defensively he's good at worst and outstanding at best.  There aren't too many guys on this team that you can say that about.

So while the Pens may be able to get a winger or two if they move Staal, I'd suggest they don't.  His poor play recently may even allow them to sign him at a discount.  And that brings me to the final reason people want Staal traded: his potential salary.  The Penguins don't exactly have money to throw around and, even if they did, they don't have the cap space to throw it.  It's going to be difficult to keep Staal under conrtact unless he follows Crosby, Malkin, Fleury and Orpik and takes a bit of a pay cut.

I think that's exactly what he will do.  At this point in time Jordan Staal has one very good NHL season and his potential to use as bargaining chips.  I doubt he's a stupid man.  After last season. he didn't want to negotiate a new conrtact because he felt he had a poor year.  If he has enough subpar year he's smart enough to know that he won't be making superstar money on his next contract.  And that's one more reason the Penguins should re-sign him.  In three years they could look back at the contract he signed this coming summer and see how they got a great deal on a potential
Selke trophy winner.  At worst they could see how they spent a reasonably small amount on a player with a lot of undeveloped potential.

The players they could get for Staal would likely end up making more money next season than Staal would so, even if you're looking at this from a purely monetary viewpoint, it doesn't make sense to trade Jordan Staal.

Of course things could change.  Staal could start racking up the points and demand six million dollars next year.  If that's the case, I hope Tampa Bay still has cap space.  But at this point in time I think it would be ridiculous to think about trading Jordan Staal.

Email this post
Subscribe to the Penguins Experience RSS Feed


Anonymous said...

Come to Toronto Jordan Staal!

In Pittsburgh, you will be unappreciated, and will always be a sideshow with Malkin and Crosby in the spot light.

Be smart. Come to a place where you'll make alot of money, live a rock star lifestyle, and be loved by millions of Leaf fans aching for a Stanley Cup. Be our #1.

Penguins Experience said...

As much as I tend to dislike the Leafs, you make a good point.
On a team like Toronto Jordan Staal would definitely be a star. It depends on whether or not he wants to be a star, of course, but if he does a place like Toronto would be a good fit for him.

Post a Comment -A Pittburgh Penguins Blog. Game previews and recaps, commentary, news and more. This is the blog to follow the NHL's Pittsburgh Penguins.
The opinions expressed the writers of this Pittsburgh Penguins blog and by those providing comments are theirs alone, and do not reflect the opinions of anyone else. While every caution has been taken to provide readers with most accurate Pittsburgh Penguins and NHL information along with honest analysis, please use your discretion before making any decisions based on the information in this blog.
This site is in no way affiliated with the Pittsburgh Penguins or the National Hockey League.
In accordance with the Fair Use Copyright Law this site uses logos and registered trademarks of the National Hockey League to convey criticism and inform the public. Photos and images on this site are used without permission but do not interfere with said owner's profit. If you own a specific image used on this site and want it removed, please e-mail us ( and we will be happy to oblige.

Penguins Experience - Pittsburgh Penguins Blog ©Layout based upon "Green Blogger Template" by Dicas Blogger.